United States. The West Point Cadets' Sword of William Rowdell Denson, West Point Class of 1934, Chief Prosecutor War Crimes Trials EUCOM 1945-1947
Includes:
1. West Point Cadets' Sword named to William Rowdell Denson (issued to cadet officers of the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York for wear when the uniform is designated as "under arms," to include formal functions, drill, parades, inspections and graduation: Sword: steel blade with a silvered finish, magnetic, engraved in Gothic style text "William Rowdell Denson" on the obverse, inscribed "U.S.M.A." (United States Military Academy) and maker marked "THE LILLEY-AMES CO. / COLUMBUS, OHIO" on the reverse, the blade measuring 810 mm in length, green felt washer at the base of the blade, the handle in bronze gilt, bearing the insignia of the United States Military Academy at the center of the crossguard, with an eagle head placed at either end of the crossguard, ribbed grip, the pommel with a spread-winged eagle on either side and finished with a scroll, the sword measuring 952 mm in length x 105 mm in width, exhibiting gilt wear; scabbard: in silvered metal, magnetic, the throat, locket and chape in bronze gilt, the locket with a hook, the chape incorporating a wide and flat tip fixture, measuring 830 mm in length, dent on the reverse, exhibiting wear in the silvering and gilt; and Carrying Case: in brown canvas, with the trim in light brown stitched in place, lined in white cotton, foldover flap with snap closure, stamped with the initials "W.D." (William Denson") on the flap, measuring 975 mm in length x 175 mm in width, exhibiting extensive wear and soiling);
2. Cap Badge (in bronze gilt, measuring 54 mm (w) x 44.5 mm (h), screwback, with both push pin points intact);
3. Cufflinks Pair (in bronze gilt, marked "KREMENTZ" on their reverses, measuring 18.5 mm (w) x 12.5 mm (h), both with intact post and fixed toggle);
4. West Point June Week 1934 Calendar (embossed black leather cover, with an imprint in silver ink and dated "1934" on the front cover, vellum insert on the inside front cover, containing eighteen pages printed in black ink, in an off-white paper stock, measuring 125 mm (w) x 175 mm (h) x 5.5 mm (d), lightly soiled on the exterior cover, the pages unaffected);
5. West Point "The Howitzer" 1934 Yearbook (greenish embossed stone pattern on the covers, the front cover bearing an eagle on a staff, inscribed "HOWITZER MCMXXXIV" in gold-coloured ink, Limited Edition of 2,300 copies, printed under the direction of Editor J. deP. Townsend Hills, Associate Editors John H. Anderson & Charles F. Tank and Business Manager Thomas L. Crystal, printed by Baker, Jones, Hausauer, Inc. of Buffalo, New York, "for the Corps of Cadets at the United States Military Academy, West Point, New York", this edition numbered "1668" in handwritten black ink, photo and biography of the owner William Dowdell Denson in this edition (flagged page), multiple un-numbered pages, printed in black and green or color inks, the initial pages and title pages on an off-white paper stock, the majority of the pages on a coated white paper stock, incorporating a few vellum inserts, measuring 230 mm (w) x 315 mm (h) x 38 mm (d), with a letter entitled "The Femmes' Number of The Pointer" and a movie listing newspaper clipping loosely inserted in the yearbook beside his photo and bio);
6. Book: "Justice at Dachau: The Trials of an American Prosecutor", by Joshua M. Greene, brown cloth cover, with dust jacket and protective clear plastic cover, signed by the author in black ink on the title page, First Edition published in 2003, published by Broadway Books, printed in the United States of America, ISBN 0-7679-0879-1, the book documenting Lieutenant Colonel Denson's work and successful convictions as Chief Military Prosecutor at the War Crimes Trials, 400 pages printed in black ink, on a white paper stock, measuring 158 mm (w) x 241 mm (h) x 34.5 mm (d));
7. Document: "The Last Words of Dr. Karl Brandt from the Landesberger Galgen" (in German, typewritten in black ink, on a thin off-white paper stock, measuring 208 mm (w) x 298 mm (h), edge evident along the bottom edge, accompanied by assorted research papers and a photocopied photograph).
Better than very fine.
Footnote: William Rowdell Denson was born on May 31, 1913 in Birmingham, Alabama. He graduated from West Point in 1934 in the rank of Second Lieutenant (10034), later achieving a Bachelor of Laws degree (LL.B.) at Harvard in 1937. Denson served in the rank of Lieutenant Colonel from 1942 to 1946 and was a Law Instructor at the United States Military Academy from 1942 to 1945. He was posted to 3rd Army Headquarters T-E from 1945 to 1946 and is noted as being the Chief Military Prosecutor at the War Crimes Trials, United States European Command (EUCOM) from 1945 to 1947.
At the time of the trials, Denson, age 32, was assigned to the Judge Advocate's Office in Europe. He would go on to help convict and execute more Nazi war criminals than any other American while serving as the Chief Military Prosecutor of those accused of running concentration camps in Germany. In the trials that Mr. Denson oversaw, the proceedings were conducted in Dachau and were presided over by American judges under the United States War Crimes Tribunal. In the Nazi war crimes trials, American military defense counsel upheld standards of professionalism even with respect to clients who had once been their enemies, and whom clear evidence showed had committed horrific acts. Seeking to uphold both international law and ideals of American justice, they vigorously defended their clients amidst cries of "victor's justice."
In four trials from 1945 to 1947, which focused on atrocities committed at the concentration camps at Dachau, Mauthausen, Buchenwald and Flossenburg, and after twenty-one months of trials, Denson secured convictions of 177 Nazis, the largest number convicted by any single prosecutor. Technically the four were "mere" concentration camps, rather than Vernichtungslager, or extermination camps, such as Auschwitz or Treblinka, but the wickednesses committed there were scarcely less egregious. Most defendants he was in charge of prosecuting in 1945 were closer to the scenes of the Nazi crimes than those in the dock in the more famous 1945-1946 trials at Nuremberg. Many Nuremberg defendants had planned the brutal acts, but the underlings who carried them out often drew harsher penalties.
Those who were in the dock before Denson, struck him as having come from fairly normal backgrounds, but he noted that exposure to violence merely generated more violence; experience of atrocity merely raised the threshold of future atrocity. Of the 177 people he prosecuted, only four were acquitted, and 132 were sentenced to death, with the rest receiving varying prison terms. It was the highwater mark for war crimes trials in Europe. A dozen more tribunals would sit in Nuremberg, but of the 185 who appeared before them, just 25 were sentenced to death.
Of those condemned to die, some had their sentences reduced on appeal, but 97 were eventually hanged. By comparison, of the 22 most prominent former Nazis who were the first to go on trial in Nuremberg, twelve received death sentences, and three were sentenced to life in prison, while four were granted lesser prison terms and three were acquitted. In twelve subsequent tribunals at Nuremberg, 185 leading personalities of the Nazi period were indicted. Of these, four committed suicide, four were ruled incompetent to stand trial, 25 were given death sentences, 20 received terms of life in prison, 97 were sent to prison for shorter periods, and 35 were acquitted.
Denson had seen war, destruction and suffering, and yet, as he remarked in an interview in 1990, what he heard as he began to gather testimony aroused disbelief. ''I'll be perfectly candid with you,'' said Mr. Denson, who was by then an elderly man, ''I thought here were some people who had been mistreated in the concentration camps and they were seeking revenge, and that they were really doing a job drawing on fantasy rather than reality. And when I questioned a number of witnesses, and they related substantially the same things, then I knew the events had occurred, because these witnesses did not have a chance to get together ahead of time and fabricate their stories.'' He said those who were convicted seemed to have had normal backgrounds, but the more violence they were exposed to, ''the more unconscionable'' they became.
The most controversial of the cases was that of Ilse Koch, the sadistic wife of the camp commandant who came to be known as the Bitch of Buchenwald, who had been accused of singling out inmates for beatings and torture that at times brought on their deaths. She had also been accused of possessing lampshades and a photo album made of tattooed human skin. Because Koch, now age 40, was pregnant when brought to trial, Denson sought and obtained a sentence of life in prison, rather than the death penalty, for her crimes against non-Germans. But a year later, General Lucius D. Clay, the senior United States military official in Germany, commuted her term to four years. Denson, by this time a civilian, called General Clay's decision ''a mockery of the administration of justice.'' Koch was then tried by a German court for her role in the deaths of German citizens and drew another life term in a German prison, where she committed suicide in 1967.
Each trial was important. However, they were overshadowed then and now, by the contemporaneous Nuremberg trial, where Supreme Court Associate Justice Robert M. Jackson was prosecuting the surviving leaders of the defeated Third Reich before a panel of international judges. The difference in resources between the two sets of trials was extraordinary, and demonstrates why Denson deserves a special place as one of history's unsung and underappreciated heroes. As an example, Justice Jackson's team numbered more than 640 staff members to prosecute twenty-two individuals. In contrast, Denson was only able to draw upon twenty persons to prosecute sixty Nazis at the Dachau trial alone.
Other individuals tried included: August Eigruber, a Nazi Gauleiter in Upper Austria, whom Denson later described as "one of the most arrogant defenders I have ever encountered", with Eigruber shouting ''Heil Hitler'' as the noose was placed around his neck; Dr. Klaus Schilling, who murdered hundreds in his so-called research for a cure for malaria; and Edwin Katzen-Ellenbogen, an American psychologist who set himself up as a privileged prisoner inside a concentration camp and killed prisoners who refused to pay him ransom. Initially, the United States government tried to keep secret the commutations and reversals. But when they were revealed, the result was a public outcry and congressional hearings, which ultimately fell on deaf ears. Denson, who was understandably frustrated by the government's actions, resigned himself to a quiet, private life.
In 1948, Denson returned to the United States, joining the Atomic Energy Commission in Washington as Chief of Litigation. He represented the commission at the spying trial of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg. In 1950, he married Constance von Francken-Sierstorpff, the daughter of a princely family he had met in Germany. He became a partner in the New York law firm of Morgan, Finnegan, Durham & Pine, litigating cases involving patents, trademarks and copyrights. In 1980, he joined Meltzer, Lippe, Goldstein, Wolf & Schlissel of Mineola, New York.
After decades of silence, in the 1990s, Denson finally started speaking publicly of his Nazi prosecution experiences, particularly motivated by the genocidal horrors committed in the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda. Denson was a recipient of the Bronze Star Medal and Commendation Ribbon (BSM-CR). He died on Sunday, December 13, 1998 at his home in Lawrence, New York, at the age of 85. In addition to his wife, he was survived by his daughters, Yvonne McQuilkin of Cambridge, Massachusetts, and Olivia Fischett of Parsippany, New Jersey, a son, William Denson Jr. of Lawrence, and five grandchildren.
Unfortunately, he did not live to see the creation of the International Criminal Court. In the book, "Justice at Dachau: The Trials of an American Prosecutor", by Joshua M. Greene, the author notes that Denson's "last wish was that the story of the Dachau trials be told, not for his own aggrandizement, but to educate future generations, that no one is genetically exempt from inhuman behavior, and that the price for avoiding such tragedy again is a vigilant defense of human rights."